The Clarion

‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

Nora+Roberts+is+a+well-known+romance+author.+Her+new+book%2C+%E2%80%9CYear+One%2C%E2%80%9D+represents+Roberts%E2%80%99+first+efforts+in+a+new+genre%3A+post-apocalyptic+horror.+The+book+did+not+live+up+to+her+%E2%80%9Cbest+seller%E2%80%9D+standards.
Back to Article
Back to Article

‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

Nora Roberts is a well-known romance author. Her new book, “Year One,” represents Roberts’ first efforts in a new genre: post-apocalyptic horror. The book did not live up to her “best seller” standards.

Nora Roberts is a well-known romance author. Her new book, “Year One,” represents Roberts’ first efforts in a new genre: post-apocalyptic horror. The book did not live up to her “best seller” standards.

ST. MARTIN'S PRESS

Nora Roberts is a well-known romance author. Her new book, “Year One,” represents Roberts’ first efforts in a new genre: post-apocalyptic horror. The book did not live up to her “best seller” standards.

ST. MARTIN'S PRESS

ST. MARTIN'S PRESS

Nora Roberts is a well-known romance author. Her new book, “Year One,” represents Roberts’ first efforts in a new genre: post-apocalyptic horror. The book did not live up to her “best seller” standards.

Jennifer Reinfried, Business Director

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Nora Roberts is a name many people are familiar with, even if they haven’t read any of her work. She specializes in romance novels, having written hundreds in multiple series and standalone alike.

Roberts has won multiple awards, even getting the title “America’s Favorite Novelist” by The New Yorker. She’s a publishing and writing sensation, pumping out book after book, starting one sometimes the day after her last one is finished, and a great number of these end up on The New York Times’ bestseller list.

Interviews with her reveal she’s a sassy woman who doesn’t take any crap and who has a pretty fantastic sense of humor.

All of this made me pick up a copy of “Year One,” one of her latest books. I can’t be caught dead reading a romance novel, but upon skimming the jacket copy, I was intrigued. “Year One” tells the story of a mysterious plague’s survivors.

The sickness – much like the flu in Stephen King’s masterpiece, “The Stand” – is called… The Doom.

Here was a well-known romance author branching out into an entirely new genre: post-apocalyptic horror. Right up my alley. Silly plague name aside, I bought my first Nora Roberts book that day, excited to start reading it once my stack of library books was complete.

“Year One,” however, is nothing but a disappointing mess.

The very first thing I noticed while reading was the descriptions, or lack thereof, that led to confusion surrounding characters and even dialogue. The way Roberts structures many of her sentences in this novel, readers are unaware of who is talking, and suddenly, a new person is in the conversation but you have no idea when they joined. Additionally, it took me a good five chapters to even realize the character named Fred was female.

That’s how lacking this book is with descriptions and dialogue tags.

Along with that, Roberts’ sentence structuring throughout “Year One” is lazy and confusing. Almost every character is pointless. Some are important sure, but every single one of them is boring and difficult to care about. The antagonists are comically terrible, like a Saturday morning cartoon bad guy style, which made me roll my eyes so many times times that they became sore. No one was conflicted; either they were “good” or they were “bad”, making this book very, well, boring.

Yep. Nora Roberts made a book about a world-ending plague absolutely boring. And, to top it all off, the pacing of the book is ridiculous. A few chapters will be crazy intense, then the ten following will be about how they are taking inventory of food over and over and wondering how to write laws for their new town…which sounds important, but no. It’s just boring. I found myself skimming through much of it, wishing it would just end.

I had high hopes for my first Nora Roberts book based on her success as an author. “Year One” even landed hundreds of five star reviews on Goodreads and other sites.

I just really don’t understand how that’s possible. I find myself constantly questioning whether or not I should even bother with a picking up a novel by this so-called favorite novelist.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Navigate Left
  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    This animated sequel was no wreck

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Get into the holiday spirit with ‘My True Love Gave To Me’

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Try out the 2 new games in the Pokémon universe

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Cosplay makes Comic Con fun

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Smashing Pumpkins concert in Madison brings back memories

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Rami Malek shines as Freddy Mercury

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Holiday specials peaked with 1974’s ‘The Year Without a Santa Claus’

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Remembering Stan ‘The Man’ Lee

  • ‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre

    Arts & Culture

    Grindelwald’s biggest crime? An unfocused plot

  • Arts & Culture

    ‘Mister Miracle’ a perfect comic run

Navigate Right
The news site of Madison Area Technical College
‘Year One’ a disappointing foray into new genre